“Loch Lomond” is one of the most popular Celtic songs around. Ireland has its own lyrics to the song with “Red is the Rose,” but Scotland’s “Loch Lomond” has historical meaning behind it, dating back to Jacobite times.
Back in the Battle of Culloden in 1746, an hour-long
battle which took place during the Jacobite Risings, leaders were either
killed on the battlefield or taken to London for show trials. During the “trials,”
they were found guilty and executed in a gruesome way.
The heads of those executed were put on pikes and paraded from
London to Edinburgh by way of the highway, which is referred to in the song as
the “high road.” This parade was meant to be a warning to those who might be
planning to rebel.
One theory is that the song is written from the perspective
of a woman who was in love with one of the men who was executed. The families of
the men executed, including their wives and girlfriends, would go to London to
watch their loved ones being tried and executed. They would travel on the “low
roads,” which were the roads and paths they were able to take on their way to
London. They would take the same way home, getting home before the heads and
corpses of their loved ones.
Another theory says that the song is a conversation between two
captured soldiers. Though the captured prisoners were given a trial, it was
mostly for show. However, the fate of the prisoners, particularly who would
live and who would be executed, was left to chance and lots. In the song, the
prisoners are discussing the bleakness of the situation.
There are many theories
about the origins of “Loch Lomond.” Some claim that the song was heard or composed
by Lady John Scott in the 1840s. Others, including the Clancy family, believe that
the song is derived from the Irish version “Red is the Rose,” though some say
the Irish lyrics seem more recent.
The song remains
popular today, though most have no clue about the dark history behind the song
and its connection to the Jacobite Rising and Culloden.
Related Articles:
-Beyond the Song: "Mo Ghile Mear": https://kiltedowl.blogspot.com/2025/09/beyond-song-mo-ghile-mear.html.html
-Beyond the Song: "The Minstrel Boy": https://kiltedowl.blogspot.com/2025/08/beyond-song-minstrel-boy.html
-Beyond the Song: “Yma o Hyd”: https://kiltedowl.blogspot.com/2025/07/beyond-song-yma-o-hyd.html







.jpg)











_by_B._L._H._Dabbs.png)